Welcome to the Impact Index
A unique tool designed to objectively assess dark tourism sites worldwide.
Encourages Reflection – Inspires you to reflect on your own travels to both local and global destinations.
Objective Criteria – While the scores are based on my observations and personal experiences, they follow objective criteria to provide insights into each site’s transformative potential.
Curated Selection – This is not an exhaustive list, but a carefully curated selection to help travelers explore, reflect, and connect with the impact these places have on history, resilience, and the human spirit.
Guidance for Personal Growth – Use this index as a guide to deepen your understanding of dark tourism destinations near and far.
Note: This version is a work in progress. Your thoughts and ideas are invaluable for improving this list, including what sites you want added. Please send any feedback to cscott@mesabacare.com
The three assessed areas include:
-
Darkness: This measures the degree to which each site is related to suffering, tragedy, death, and the macabre.
-
Educational Value: This is based on the knowledge visitors can gain from the experience, including exhibits, tour guides, and signage.
-
Emotional Impact: This measures the potential for each site to emotionally affect and transform its visitors.
Darkness
-
10/10: Site of extreme historical tragedy or atrocity.
-
8/10: Place associated with considerable suffering.
-
6/10: Site of historical significance with some dark elements.
-
4/10: Site with minor dark historical significance.
-
2/10: Place with very limited dark historical relevance.
-
0/10: No association with dark events or history.
Educational Value
-
10/10: Provides comprehensive information.
-
8/10: Contains solid educational material.
-
6/10: Provides limited educational content.
-
4/10: Very little educational content, possibly just historical markers.
-
2/10: Negligible educational content, possibly just a mention/plaque.
-
0/10: No educational content or information provided.
Emotional Impact
-
10/10: Profoundly moving.
-
8/10: Strongly emotional.
-
6/10: Some emotional impact.
-
4/10: Limited emotional resonance.
-
2/10: Hardly any emotional impact.
-
0/10: No emotional impact at all.
Click Text to See Image
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 30/30 Description: Site of one of history's most horrific genocides, Auschwitz stands as a solemn reminder of the atrocities of the Holocaust.
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 30/30 Description: Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park in Japan commemorates the victims of the atomic bomb.
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 29/30 Description: Located near Phnom Penh, Cambodia, these sites reflect the atrocities committed by the Khmer Rouge. The Killing Fields were mass execution sites, and Tuol Sleng was a former high school turned into a notorious torture prison.
Darkness: 9/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 29/30 Description: Located at Ground Zero, this site honors the victims of the September 11 attacks and provides a detailed account of the events and their aftermath.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The Anne Frank House, located in Amsterdam, Netherlands, is the preserved hiding place where Anne Frank wrote her famous diary during World War II. (Phone: Tobias Niepel)
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The Chernobyl Exclusion Zone, including the ghost town of Pripyat, is the site of the catastrophic 1986 nuclear disaster. Once home to workers of the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant, Pripyat was evacuated shortly after the explosion, leaving behind a city frozen in time.escribe your image
Darkness: 9/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The Normandy Beaches in France, specifically Omaha, Utah, Gold, Juno, and Sword, are the historic sites of the D-Day landings.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: Robben Island, located off the coast of Cape Town, South Africa, is where Nelson Mandela was imprisoned for 18 of his 27 years in detention.
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The Kigali Genocide Memorial in Rwanda honors the memory of more than 250,000 people who were killed during the 1994 genocide, offering insight into the events and promoting peace and reconciliation.
Darkness: 9/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The Whitney Plantation in Wallace, Louisiana, is one of the few plantations in the United States that is entirely dedicated to telling the story of slavery.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 27/30 Description: Pompeii, an ancient Roman city in Italy, was buried under volcanic ash and pumice after the eruption of Mount Vesuvius in AD 79, preserving the lives and deaths of its inhabitants.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 27/30 Description: The Valley of the Kings is the ancient burial site of Egyptian pharaohs and nobles. Best known for the tomb of King Tutankhamun, it offers insight into ancient Egyptian beliefs about death and the afterlife.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 26/30 Description: Port Arthur was one of the most notorious penal colonies in the British Empire, where convicts were sent for harsh punishments and brutal conditions. The site witnessed countless stories of suffering and escape attempts, making it a haunting reminder of Australia’s colonial past and its use as a penal settlement.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 26/30 Description: Gettysburg, the site of one of the most important battles of the American Civil War, serves as a powerful reminder of the cost of war and the struggle for freedom.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 26/30 Description: The Berlin Wall Memorial commemorates the division of Germany and the Cold War. The site honors those who died attempting to cross from East to West Berlin, symbolizing the struggles for freedom.
Darkness: 7/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 26/30 Description: Jerusalem is home to some of the most significant religious sites in the world, including the Western Wall, the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, the Dome of the Rock, and the Al-Aqsa Mosque.
Darkness: 9/10 Educational Value: 6/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 25/30 Description: Aokigahara Forest, located at the base of Mount Fuji, is notorious for the high number of suicides that have taken place there.
Darkness: 7/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 25/30 Description: Alcatraz Island in San Francisco Bay was once a high-security prison housing notorious criminals like Al Capone.
Darkness: 9/10 Educational Value: 7/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 25/30 Description: The Paris Catacombs are a labyrinth of tunnels beneath the city containing the remains of over six million people.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 8/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 25/30 Description: The Hỏa Lò Prison in Hanoi, Vietnam, was used by the French colonists and later during the Vietnam War to hold prisoners of war.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 7/10 Overall Score: 24/30 Description: The Tower of London has a grim history as a royal prison and execution site, including the beheading of Anne Boleyn.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 9/10 Emotional Impact: 8/10 Overall Score: 25/30 Description: Easter Island is famous for its Moai statues, but its history is marked by environmental destruction and societal collapse.
Darkness: 7/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 8/10 Overall Score: 25/30 Description: The Terracotta Army is part of the tomb complex of China’s first emperor, Qin Shi Huang.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 8/10 Emotional Impact: 8/10 Overall Score: 24/30 Description: Salem, Massachusetts, is infamous for the 1692 witch trials, where 20 people were executed due to mass hysteria and accusations of witchcraft.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 7/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 24/30 Description: Leap Castle in Ireland is considered one of the most haunted castles in the world, with a bloody and violent history dating back to the 13th century.
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 6/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 26/30 Description: The site of the 1890 massacre of Lakota Sioux by U.S. military forces, Wounded Knee is marked by profound tragedy and deep emotional impact, though educational resources on-site may be limited.
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 30/30 Description: The Nanjing Massacre Memorial commemorates the brutal events of 1937, providing an extensive educational experience and deeply moving emotional impact as it honors the victims and preserves the memory of one of history's most harrowing wartime atrocities.
Darkness: 10/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 30/30 Description: The slave fortresses on the West African coast, such as Cape Coast Castle and Elmina Castle, stand as stark reminders of the horrors of the transatlantic slave trade, offering profound educational insight and a deeply emotional experience that underscores the immense human suffering and resilience tied to these historic sites.
Darkness: 9/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 9/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The Roman Colosseum, an iconic structure known for its brutal gladiatorial combats and public spectacles involving death and violence, offers significant educational insight into ancient Roman society and evokes a powerful emotional response through its dark history of bloodshed and human suffering.
Darkness: 8/10 Educational Value: 10/10 Emotional Impact: 10/10 Overall Score: 28/30 Description: The site of the 1941 surprise attack that propelled the United States into World War II, Pearl Harbor offers comprehensive educational resources and an emotionally powerful experience that honors the lives lost and reflects on the profound historical significance of the event.